The error code P0650, ECM or Cluster?
#1
The error code P0650, ECM or Cluster?
Hello,
I have 05 Suburban 1500 FF.
First of all, I would appreciate it if you refer to my last post regarding P0650.
I was told from the dealership tec to replace both ECM and Cluster because the code P0650 popped up when diagnosed.
Before that, I went there to check why the check engine light never came on when ignition key on without engine start. (I bought used one without checking this issue b/c I am definitely ignorant of a car mechanism)
So, yesterday, I got the ECM replaced in the dealership paying $900
BTW, are all the GM ECM "remanufactured"? I thought it's brand new, but the part guy said, "all the ECM selling here are remanufactured".
Anyway, after the ECM replacement, the tec said,
"the code p0650 is SOLVED, but the CEL still doesn't come on, so it's time to replace the cluster, and I am sure 100% the CEL will come on when cluster replaced".
So, I really wonder if the P0650 is from the ECM or just Cluster, OR both?
I was in a kinda panic.
Can it be problems of both ECM and Cluster at the same time when the code P0650 pops up?
Now I am really in a worry that I should have the cluster replaced paying another $720.
Actually, I have to say I have lived in America for just 2yrs as well as got the first GM truck. So, I have no idea of any repair knowledge nor dealership policy. I have no one around me to help me regarding this issue.
So, just please help me.
The only problem was that the CEL doesn't come on when the ignition key on before engine starts, that's it. EVERYTHING other than this issue is OK.
The reason I eagerly repair this issue is that I heard the emission test will fail if the CEL doesn't work.
But, I already replaced the ECM in the dealership and was also told to replace cluster because according to the tec, something wrong in the cluster WIRE happened.
I think I can remove the cluster and put it back but can't figure out what the WIRES are and how to check if they are OK.
Where should I go? ...
Thanks for reading with all my best.
I have 05 Suburban 1500 FF.
First of all, I would appreciate it if you refer to my last post regarding P0650.
I was told from the dealership tec to replace both ECM and Cluster because the code P0650 popped up when diagnosed.
Before that, I went there to check why the check engine light never came on when ignition key on without engine start. (I bought used one without checking this issue b/c I am definitely ignorant of a car mechanism)
So, yesterday, I got the ECM replaced in the dealership paying $900
BTW, are all the GM ECM "remanufactured"? I thought it's brand new, but the part guy said, "all the ECM selling here are remanufactured".
Anyway, after the ECM replacement, the tec said,
"the code p0650 is SOLVED, but the CEL still doesn't come on, so it's time to replace the cluster, and I am sure 100% the CEL will come on when cluster replaced".
So, I really wonder if the P0650 is from the ECM or just Cluster, OR both?
I was in a kinda panic.
Can it be problems of both ECM and Cluster at the same time when the code P0650 pops up?
Now I am really in a worry that I should have the cluster replaced paying another $720.
Actually, I have to say I have lived in America for just 2yrs as well as got the first GM truck. So, I have no idea of any repair knowledge nor dealership policy. I have no one around me to help me regarding this issue.
So, just please help me.
The only problem was that the CEL doesn't come on when the ignition key on before engine starts, that's it. EVERYTHING other than this issue is OK.
The reason I eagerly repair this issue is that I heard the emission test will fail if the CEL doesn't work.
But, I already replaced the ECM in the dealership and was also told to replace cluster because according to the tec, something wrong in the cluster WIRE happened.
I think I can remove the cluster and put it back but can't figure out what the WIRES are and how to check if they are OK.
Where should I go? ...
Thanks for reading with all my best.
#2
CF Beginner
Join Date: Aug 2014
Location: Nottingham, UK
Posts: 10
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Just googled your error code and came across this P0650 Malfunction Indicator Lamp (MIL) Control Circuit
If you read further down near the bottom it gives some info on things to check.
Hope it helps
If you read further down near the bottom it gives some info on things to check.
Hope it helps
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post